Laverda Forum and controversy and change

Status
Not open for further replies.
It wasn't easy to understand Jouni?s english but I understand he expressed the fact that people he knows and knows of have left the forum due to feeling denigrated by others who claim to be experts. It took him quite an effort and he is concerned for the future of the forum.
 
The only thing I understood is that the poster has an above average opinion of him/herself and his or her country, whatever that is. And that all others are idiots. Which is what he/she is criticizing in everyone else.

Palmelli 180 said:
The only thing I understood from that post is that apparently I am a "Lurker".
 
At least it is food for thoughts. If someone takes the time to write publicly his/hers frustration about the forum, we should give credits and respect to that person and at least sit back and think a bit about it and see if we are part of the problem or can be part of a solution.

I would not ever by any means call myself an expert, but I contribute a lot. It is a natural effect, that some people like what you write and some don't. And sometimes, what you write comes across different than intended. Be it for language issues, or because the reader has a certain mood and reads everything with this mood in mind and therefore filters the words accordingly, which can twist the sense of the words/the intention massively...

Being part of several forums, I can tell that most of them have less than 10% of the members contributing regularly. I don't think that this forum is any different in that regard. You have people registering almost every other day, not all of them stay and for some, it is a real shame.

BUT... To change the forum, it takes the 90% to change... They need to post more and make it a place as they want it to be. If they do not want this, they can either live with the way it is or - unfortunately - will be leaving one day. Silently or with a big bang.

BUT2... I have seen many coming back after some time... Grant (hey - I found the swing back to the original message of this thread!  :D ) might be one of them coming back one day. He is - as far as I can tell with my limited touch points with him - a great guy and has a lot of experiences. Others might have different experience and think different of him, I don't know. Pretty sure that is with almost everyone on this forum - some like you, some don't. No difference to real life, right?  ;)

So - coming back to Jouni and in respect to what he wrote, I would like to state once and for ever that me personally, I like the forum a lot; I am NO EXPERT, just have some experiences. I have NO education in any mechanics related direction, I am selling software. Laverda is my pure fun (and sometimes burden...) since almost 30 years. I have done things to my bike experts told me never to do. Sometimes I was right, sometimes they were. At the end, we both learned a lot in the past 30 years and that is the biggest part of the fun for me.

In one point (at least) though I would like to disagree with Jouni: I am always amazed with what developments come up here and how much they are appreciated - even by the experts. Julian with his engine work being one extreme lately, but even Red's work or others. New frame concepts, new tools like side-stand kits, different ignition systems, even 4-valve heads and other stuff. I love it all and can't wait to see the next levels of it.

So - if I pissed of anyone, it was absolutely unintentionally and I do apologize! But please - show the respect to others if you feel offended and send them a private message and let them know how you feel. I bet 90% or more is just hot air and missunderstandings. I hope, at least...  ;)
 
MotoJouni said:
I'm one of the people who have decided not to post anymore, but I still randomly read something.
Due to some harsh criticism of people who have decided to leave I tell this.

I'm of different generation than most people in this site. In my country people are always required to tell the truth, and therefore in my culture it would be almost lying if I don't tell this and it is very fair if I do so. This principle helps people to live in peace in my country, even thought it means people must face the challenges. People should be somehow accepted first in this site, in my country that happens only in 1% gangs. I'm a young Laverdist grown up my whole life with Laverda. I'm a motorcyclist in third generation, in my family we have had motorcycles since 1940's, some complete rebuilds durings last around 60 years, also Laverdas last 48 years in close relation to local importer, etc. I tell now very honestly and directly what kind of things are shown to me. I tried to nicen this a lot more but found it started to miss its points and it is a little bit harsh. I'm sorry I was not able to do it more nicely. This is a harsh forum anyway.

There's mostly three reasons why I have stopped taking part:

1. Setting up limits on what is and what could be. A form of fundamentalism, there's often just one some kind of very strange idea of what is acceptable. And that's final then. One form of it is, for example, if someone have seen 1% of these bikes and then say everything applies to rest of the 99%. In some cases it is true, some cases it is not true. I consider it is sometimes inductive fallacy.
Another example is that I should always forget everything what is already achieved with these motorcycles and engineering in my country, and I think it is often much more advanced than what is accepted to be even said in this site.

2. Crazy people just simply broke the bikes theirselves in this forum including some of the "experts" and "engineers". According to VERY BASIC ENGINEERING that is generally taught in my country, from extremely detailed point of view, around every second component in these motorcycles is NOT meant to work how described in this forum even if I exclude jokes. Often went very wrong from the very beginning. In my country many motorcyclists even without no any kind of education in engineering often think that many of them are obvious. In my country some people who read this often have no any kind of clue what the heck they have taught there abroad.

Also in my country, nothing, never, ever, not even once, breaks down without a reason. Much related to this, also a couple of Laverdists and other motorcyclists in my country have told to me that this site is often "absolutely no any kind of clue about anything." Few years back I also received here some private messages in where the senders said they have no any kind of use for the strange answers in the forum. When I was in school it was often said that my country used to have best education in the whole world. I never believed it but when reading this forum I sometimes wonder did it even worked somehow.

Comments are often such how many decades someone has bodgered motorcycles and they therefore have almost nothing to learn about the bikes anymore. Do you guys really think that I, who have passed some parts from doctor's degree in engineering and have all of the lower degrees, should believe that it is somehow possible to learn everything about old motorcycles? Rather, there are an unlimited number of higher levels. There's some people close to me who have worked with some models of these motorcycles last 50 years or so. These people have suggested that I should ask here if you guys mean that you still didn't learnt and with this attitude you have already stopped to learn decades ago.

Two examples. In this forum in the accepted conversations people recommend to use much lower octane rating fuel that reads in the owner's manual, even if higher was available, and then repair exactly those faults from the engines why there is the fuel recommendation. People put mineral oil to Brembo brake or hydraulic clutch systems swearing how crap stuff Brembo has supplied. Brembo has never meant them to work with mineral oil based brake fluid but with the more common glycol ether based brake fluid. Generally there is no suitable sealing material that can withstand both of these different fluids, the material is different for different fluids. These two examples are completely lunatic ideas in my country and I think I'm easily able to tell around 50 similar ones from this site that are commonly accepted unquestionable truth on here at least in the conversations and discussed again and again. Trying to start a conversation it starts a fight. In my country if someone has too much testosterone it doesn't make him a Harley mechanic.

3. If, for example, 100 different persons get offended and detele their accounts from this site it doesn't count anything at all. Just a funny joke and healthy motorcycling culture that 100 did this in short time, really? In my country these kind of people are generally considered to be, and sometimes even called "fifteen year old moped guys". Generally people from my country will never tell this to you because it can be an issue about respecting other people. That is what they secretly think. I tell these now because it is fair and this site has often went far beyond what can be considered respecting other people. Several Laverdists from my country have personally told me that they have "absolutely nothing at all to say to anything this kind of." It is very good there is Ron in this site telling you that you are moped guys.


Things mentioned above have choosen people who are still left, and defined "accepted" point of views. Often they are people who either believe in some very strange thoughts from this forum because of various reasons or people who often hold back taking part to certain conversations because they already know what kind the discussions will be. This is also one big reason why there are a lot of "lurkers" who don't want to post anything at all. These also apply to experts, things such who are still left or not, or what they say or don't say is also often choosen this way. These things have went extremely far and formed an extremely strange bubble.

Dear Paul LeClair, your site has really lost its way. Life is too short for such a non-sense. It is also more about drinking beer than Laverda. Think the challenges above what ever being the route this site will take.


Happy New Year to all,
-Jouni

Hi Jouni

this Laverda site has evolved over the twenty plus years it has operated after being started from scratch. I started this thread to discuss change here. Options considered range from closing the forum down and leaving the Laverda discussions to the various FaceBook groups that have arisen and grown, to leaving things as they are with very limited moderation and see what change or growth or decline happens, or to trying to force "positive" change here through some means.

People who participate here choose to do so, and personally I still fall in the camp of continuing with very minimal moderation. "Positive" change is a very subjective thing, especially if it is sought to be imposed on others, which is unattractive to many, if not most. Differences of opinion in technical matters is not something I am even qualified to judge or to interfere in. I believe people are smart enough and discerning enough to form and follow their own opinions, and determine facts for themselves.

Rob and I and the other moderators remain open to any and all suggestions. What would you suggest we do differently?

Paul LeClair
 
English may seem an easy language to communicate in but it absolutely isn't. A lot of meaning is hidden and expressions are deliberately misused to provoke reaction. It's a bit of a game if you know how to play it. It is easy to get the wrong end of the stick but I can tell you this, some of the best people I've met post on here and most other sites are well below the standard of this one if you need help and advice.
Stick with it  ;)
 
Apparently, Journi seems to be mainly pissed off by technical views aired here.

One topic Journi outlined and massively criticized is the use/recommendation of incorrect fuel octane ratings.  However, I'd suggest Journi to take a peek beyond his own horizons and pay more attention to where the particular person is located when speaking out recommendations.  The US of A for instance, generally states/uses a completely different octane standard to Europe, resulting in far lower figures stated for exactly the same fuel.  Much the same for many other global regions.  Quite simple to read up on this topic; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octane_rating  The general concensus here is to use the best possible fuel available, irrespective of what it says on the tin, not entirely nonsense imho.  Unfortunately, the hi-octane fuels that Laverda specified at the time of writing their owner manuals are no longer freely available on garage forecourts.  We'll just have to make do with what we have.

Also, fluid recommendation for Brembo brake and clutch systems.  AfaIk, Brembo has only ever recommended using DOT4 fluid, which SHOULD be the same concoction world-wide.  In the past, I have recommended using synthetic DOT5 fluid, BUT ONLY with a completey fresh set of uncontaminated seals, in all connected components.  I have found this to work quite well.  I have given up on this idea due to the unavailabilty of DOT5 in emergencies, because it shouldn't be mixed with anything else.  A better option is DOT5.1, which is meant as a direct replacement for DOT4, and again, SHOULD be the same wherever you source it.  It is also mixable with DOT4, which is fine in emergencies (like on top of an alpine pass on a Sunday afternoon, can't be very choosy there).  Can't remember anybody recommending using mineral oils or similar... (but I'd piss in my brake reservoir if it gets me home :D)

As this is a truely international forum communicating entirely in english, misunderstandings can quickly spring up for people with lesser understandings of the language.  Adding to that, cultural differences can be quite misleading for some, I've fallen on my face a couple of times by using expressions that were part of normal aussie speech while I grew up there, but are now seen as politically totally incorrect or even downright dangerous, at least in many parts of the english-speaking world and completely misunderstood in the remainder.

It is sad to see people leave, no matter how large or small their contributions were.  But, it's their decision and should be respected as such.  Yes, there's a shit-megaton of bullshit floating around, even in this fine forum.  In fact, a load of off-topic BS has popped up in this thread during the time I needed to write this.  For my part, I just try to stay out of it and comment only if truely dangerous technical "facts" are thrown around.  Although I have 40 years of experience with these bikes, work on them professionally and have the qualifications to do so in Germany (which is no mean feat in itself), I'm often surprised at what pops up here, I have no problem with learning something new.  I do consider myself to be able to differentiate what is or isn't feasible and conclusive.

Let's all hope for a better 2021 and we're able to leave the shit that 2020 brought us behind.

My 2 cents,
piet
 
12 Months ago the members on this forum got together and raised a very substantial sum of money to help me out after the bushfires which destroyed ours and many other homes in Australia. A very humbling experience and we are still 6 months away from a new home.
When you go back and see what's left = nothing, not even a tooth brush, the hopelessness of the situation hits you. And I'm not alone.
I will forever be thankful for this, many of the people on this forum I have never met. But we share a common interest.

There have been others that have been helped out as well, so guys I hope it continues.

I'm no techno genius, and much help and advice has always been appreciated, and reciprocated by myself when able to help.
Yes I talk a bit off shit now and again, but have always believed if you give it be prepared to get it back.

Regards Ian.
 
look what happened to visordown and its ex forum, now clickbait advertising don't let it happen here. it's almost impossible a lot of the time to have any type of constructive discussion on FB IMO
 
I can sympathise with some of points Jouni raises; all of us have some input when it comes to a problem raised, unfortunately some of the advice given tends to be poo pooed or ignored by 'the experts'.
Speaking personally, I have often experienced the problem in question and have posted how I overcame it, only to be shot down by the usual suspects or completely ignored.
Most of the time I no longer bother giving an opinion and I suspect I'm not the only one.
 
Laverda is my passion, it is not just a hobby.  This forum is my community, it is where I go every day to talk to my neighbours.

If my community was broken, I would jump in to help repair it, not leave.

If my motorcycle was not working properly, I would repair it, not abandon it.

I therefore ask that if one of my neighbours is unhappy with an aspect of this community, jump in and help fix it, don?t leave.

There is a lot of love here. 
 
With regards to issues of a technical nature, I work in a motorcycle workshop with 3 other mechanics, all of us with over 35 years experience in the trade. We share our opinions regularly on how to overcome a problem, and try and keep egos out of it. No one mechanic says this is the way to fix it, ?my way or the highway?, it is a team effort.  The one working on the problem then absorbs all the ideas and works to a solution. Without that teamwork there would be a lot of broken motorcycles that didn?t get fixed.

If you are using this forum merely for technical solutions and not as a community, then you are missing the good bits.

Marty
 
martymoose said:
Laverda is my passion, it is not just a hobby.  This forum is my community, it is where I go every day to talk to my neighbours.

If my community was broken, I would jump in to help repair it, not leave.

If my motorcycle was not working properly, I would repair it, not abandon it.

I therefore ask that if one of my neighbours is unhappy with an aspect of this community, jump in and help fix it, don?t leave.

There is a lot of love here.

Marty, that has to be the best ever post on this subject  ....... you?ve summed it up perfectly.

 
I like any post that references Ron calling out moped guys! Anyone & everyone on this forum should post & contribute as you never know who it will help be it about a parts supplier or tech/repair experience, etc. I liken this forum to a bunch of guys hanging out in a neighborhood bar-you have the regulars & those who are here for the first time and everyone in between. When you are here for the first time you sit back & get a feel for the place. You're respectful, you appreciate the regulars (forum admins) & be sure not to offend anyone. In short order you find there are guys you get along with & others you don't. Maybe you become a regular or just stop in a few times a year-your choice, but always try to be appreciative & respectful...
 
Even the most experienced Expert can be wrong, nobody's perfect. I agree with Piet's fuel comments, where are you going to get 5 star unleaded anyway. But I also hear lots who don't use our highest octane, 98 octan in Oz and say it loses its volatiles quickly or some other reason and use 95. That's their opinion and that's just fine. Read it all and decide for yourself. The more discussion the more we all learn, I am about to ask here if there are any other ways I can stop my Primary adjuster bolt from leaking, I have some basic ideas as to how to fix this but there is bound to be ways I haven't thought of, plus it generates hopefully replies and if that stops we all might as well leave. I just read the next post and agree 100%, it would be great if you got on with everybody you meet in life, but that NEVER happens. I just try and smile while avoiding confrontations, and that can be easier said than achieved sometimes. Some people love a blue
 
We are all talking the same language here and I guess as far as some of our "country of origin habits go" we will never all get that.
As Piet said being an Australian origin we are very carefree and loose and as a show of affection with our mates "hang shit on each other"
If you didnt get that it could be seen as an insult to the wrong person, I remember whilst in Germany Piet told me about how the Germans can be seen to be very rigid in their approach so I guess its horses for courses.
I like many have many friends that I have met here some in person that I class as lifelong friends.
Journi I hope you and other lurkers join in and don't take anything too seriously.
Happy new year everyone.
 
martymoose said:
Laverda is my passion, it is not just a hobby.  This forum is my community, it is where I go every day to talk to my neighbours.

If my community was broken, I would jump in to help repair it, not leave.

If my motorcycle was not working properly, I would repair it, not abandon it.

I therefore ask that if one of my neighbours is unhappy with an aspect of this community, jump in and help fix it, don?t leave.

There is a lot of love here.
(congrats)
 
martymoose said:
Laverda is my passion, it is not just a hobby.  This forum is my community, it is where I go every day to talk to my neighbours.

If my community was broken, I would jump in to help repair it, not leave.

If my motorcycle was not working properly, I would repair it, not abandon it.

I therefore ask that if one of my neighbours is unhappy with an aspect of this community, jump in and help fix it, don?t leave.

There is a lot of love here.

Marty,

You have really nailed it. I have always believed that if you want to change or improve a group, a club or an organization; join it.

As LBJ said of Hoover, better have him inside the tent pissing out, than outside pissing in!

So my 2 cents worth says if anyone is thinking of leaving, please stay. We can all learn from each other, whether it be about brake fluid or different cultures. We are never too cool for school.

Cheers

Bottler
 
I read the PaulLeClair's words at the beginning of this 3d, that words are so clear and straight, so representative.

Actually on rare occasion I have had the feeling of true community as this forum is, where people help each other even, in my case, I have been here for few weeks.
It is, therefore, with gratitude that I avail myself of this occasion to say thank you to all of this community for the help and the efforts and for keeping this brand alive.


With Love.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top