Laverda Forum and controversy and change

Status
Not open for further replies.
Social media are one thing, forums another.

As for me, I'm more of a friend of the forums. For me a forum like this one has the atmosphere of an old Italian village. Usually you'll find all important folk in the piazza.

You talk, you hang shit on others, every now and then a few braggarts come by. Sometimes it gets more serious, you listen to those who've a lot to say, sometimes you'll be able to help others out, overall you can learn a lot.

OK, the beautiful women are largely absent ...  8)

You can be gone for days, but when you get back, everything goes on in the piazza as usual.
I never want to miss it!
:)

Cheers
Jo
 
Paul LeClair said:
Hi Jouni

this Laverda site has evolved over the twenty plus years it has operated after being started from scratch. I started this thread to discuss change here. Options considered range from closing the forum down and leaving the Laverda discussions to the various FaceBook groups that have arisen and grown, to leaving things as they are with very limited moderation and see what change or growth or decline happens, or to trying to force "positive" change here through some means.

People who participate here choose to do so, and personally I still fall in the camp of continuing with very minimal moderation. "Positive" change is a very subjective thing, especially if it is sought to be imposed on others, which is unattractive to many, if not most. Differences of opinion in technical matters is not something I am even qualified to judge or to interfere in. I believe people are smart enough and discerning enough to form and follow their own opinions, and determine facts for themselves.

Rob and I and the other moderators remain open to any and all suggestions. What would you suggest we do differently?

Paul LeClair

Hi Paul,

For the suggestion. Because this forum has been so long and developed to what it is, I think it is not possible to somehow completely invent it again or alter its basic principles or values. Agree that this is much better than anything in Facebook. This is a question that easily goes to something that has already been suggested and people have no much will to accept it.

However, I know almost ten different persons who have privately told me that they feel pissed off with this forum. Some of them are from different countries, but all of them are around 50-68 year old males who own at least one Laverda motorcycle. If even I know so many, I think there must be a lot of them and I think lack of participants starts to be a real problem to this site. I don't know more to suggest than two alternatives. Seems if nothing is done there's almost no-one left soon. Often the issue is about those ongoing "handbags", many people are tired because there is just so much of them going all the time. Can't something more to be done to them, even slightly more moderation for worst ones if necessary? Even a small difference may change the general atmosphere and therefore may also solve some other problems. If this is not the route people want to take, then it isn't. If there is no better ideas, then it is a decision with all of the known consequences. Don't know what else I can say.

Everyone: Thanks for all of the replies, hope I didn't much offended people. In next rally I would hear I'm also a moped guy or something similar, I know some pissed off lurkers are spying. ;)

-Jouni
 
As Paul has said, folk come to the forum because they choose to.  As far as I am aware, it has never been promoted or advertised in an effort to attract members. It can be viewed without registering so really is open to all.

A quick scan of the forum stats reveals that we have just under 2,000 members.  When Laverdapedia folded in 2010 there were 1115.  Over the last 5 years around 300 have joined each year.  (I occasionally prune the list of those who join but haven't logged on since their registration and have never posted). A large proportion of the 2,000 have been inactive for a long period of time. Nevertheless, in the last month some 500 members have logged on and/or posted.

I know a few folk have visited us and decided that they don't care for the treatment they received which is very disappointing.  I'm still here because I value it as a resource; have made some great friends and appreciate the fact that it is largely self-moderating.  Yes, some posts can be robust, irrelevant or frankly crap but I can filter that for myself - I guess Laverda owners and enthusiasts can be as idiosyncratic as their bikes!  The knowledge, skills and expertise that is readily and freely shared here is just amazing. 

Rob
 
Taking offence from a public forum isn?t a new phenomenon. I definitely recognise occasionally posts that have the potential to offend and have (very rarely) called it out.
On the whole though I believe that anyone using this forum has to bring their own ?filter? with them. Whether this is used to weed out crap advice or simply to focus you on the things that interest you, for me personally it?s a must.
Have to say I really can?t recall reading anything that was technically way off the mark that that I took any notice of. My technical filter at work.
The social side of things is a tad different. There is a clear core ?community ? here and that may account for much of the piss taking (friendly ridicule or teasing). Again, your filter is your friend.
 
In my experience, this forum is way better than any other bike forums I've been involved with. By a long way. I think we have a lot to be thankful for.


I was a member of the Ducati forum for a while (probably still am because I never actually de-listed myself) but I haven't been there for years. Of course there are some decent people on there but way too many tosspot wankers posting complete bollocks. Also more than a few who seem to be there for the sole purpose of putting down other peoples' comments. It seemed to me like a toxic place to be so I stopped going there.

I'm also a member of the Benelli forum, which I joined for technical info. There's some very helpful tech gurus on there who share their knowledge freely (just like here) and the general vibe of the forum is OK. So I have a look in there from time to time, but there's rarely much of interest going on unless someone has a technical issue that interests me. There seem to be a lot of younger guys (AKA millennial snowflakes) who have a whole different way of thinking to me. I guess that's because Benelli is still a current brand so many of the owners are young people, perhaps on their first bike. Some of them behave like children. I recall an exchange I had with a young bloke who posted a video of himself riding like an maniac through traffic. I said something like "if you're going to ride like an idiot, then you should at least wear gloves" (he was bare handed). He got all hurt and upset that I should criticise his riding style and lack of safety gear, and said I should have been a bit more gentle about it and at offer some positive comment to offset the negative, like praising his pretty bike or acknowledging his riding skill. WTF? I tend to call a spade a spade, so I just responded to him by saying "Sorry mate, I don't speak millennial."

I find that you can speak your mind on this forum and 99.9% of the time it's OK. Sure, not everyone will agree with everyone else, but members here are tolerant enough to understand that differences of opinion are part of life, and not stomp off in a hissy fit. I'm aware of a few occasions that I've annoyed someone else, but I've never done it intentionally. If I've ever actually offended anyone (as distinct from just annoying them), then I sincerely apologise. I never meant to do that either.

Stay safe folks and enjoy the lovely summer weather. Commiserations to you miserable buggers shivering in the northern hemisphere winter.  :D
 
IAG:
I like any post that references Ron calling out moped guys!

Thank you: Ron.

------------------------

PS: I met a young Japanese Girl on a 650 Katakana street racing Toronto in mid 70's whom could put you to shame.

Truly a fearless rider - Never scored 1st base ;o(

She lost every bike except for my Breganzie 70 750 SF0 right to her door.

She was somewhat shocked to see a Leprechaun when Helmets were removed ;o(

What a let down; I looked like Johnny Depp or Keanu Reeves back then and made $40,000 a year.

Then I had to ride some 600 miles NORTH in the early dawn just to get back home and go to work for the next morning !

Gotta Love our Breganzies - Women are something else - Hope there a few Woman in this Forum to Speak Out ;o)

 
I really would like Women to get get into this Forum - After they are our better half ?

Perhaps a Question like what's it's like living with a Hubby or a Friend obsessive with a Breganzie ?

Obsessive Breganzie I was but had to give her up when married -  basically because she's a dangerous moped !

My 130LB Wife could ride a 600lb Stead Horse but refused to ride a 300lb 650cc Yamaha Shadow - Go Figure.
 
Forums are for sharing passions, and certain passions have certain community. It could be for historical reason, habit or tradition, I don't know, I'm not an anthropologist, but mechanical's world is far from women as pineapple is far from pizza, well you can put together but...
I joined a stitching forum for recommendation regarding how sewing my saddle. My user name is Claretta (to avoid suspicion), it is plenty of charming girls ready for giving you an help and the emoticons are pink and heart-shaped and they spend time chatting about how come there are so few males in their "so exciting" community!

:D
 
MotoJouni said:
Hi Paul,

For the suggestion. Because this forum has been so long and developed to what it is, I think it is not possible to somehow completely invent it again or alter its basic principles or values. Agree that this is much better than anything in Facebook. This is a question that easily goes to something that has already been suggested and people have no much will to accept it.

However, I know almost ten different persons who have privately told me that they feel pissed off with this forum. Some of them are from different countries, but all of them are around 50-68 year old males who own at least one Laverda motorcycle. If even I know so many, I think there must be a lot of them and I think lack of participants starts to be a real problem to this site. I don't know more to suggest than two alternatives. Seems if nothing is done there's almost no-one left soon. Often the issue is about those ongoing "handbags", many people are tired because there is just so much of them going all the time. Can't something more to be done to them, even slightly more moderation for worst ones if necessary? Even a small difference may change the general atmosphere and therefore may also solve some other problems. If this is not the route people want to take, then it isn't. If there is no better ideas, then it is a decision with all of the known consequences. Don't know what else I can say.

Everyone: Thanks for all of the replies, hope I didn't much offended people. In next rally I would hear I'm also a moped guy or something similar, I know some pissed off lurkers are spying. ;)

-Jouni

Hi Jouni

thanks for the response.

in relation to moderation, there actually is likely more moderation than folks realize, Rob and I and others are fairly direct about it but don't make a big show of it. If Rob or I see something that is really WAY out of line, we quietly make it disappear. There is also the "Report a post" feature that gets used, all the moderators get notified of any complaint, and one or more of us decides how to respond and what to do about the complaint. We usually contact the poster being complained about, and the complainant, and then decide what to do, if anything. Actions range from working things about between the parties, to deleting the thread entirely, or to responding with a moderators comment/opinion and maybe locking the thread to prevent more posts but leaving the original thread up for anyone to see and judge for themselves. Commenting and locking the thread happened her just recently, in relation to one member complaining about business dealings with another member. We allowed both to air their positions, then we locked the thread but left it available. That same dispute between the same two members was also on the FaceBook groups and got really ugly with many uninformed folks piling on on both sides. I prefer the way we chose to deal with it.

I am pleased that you, and others have aired your views, Valuable input.  There has never been any grand plan behind this forum, it just kind of happened mostly by itself, has evolved and changed organically. Rob and I have refused the various purchase offers from commercial interests, not for us to profit from the members participation. My 35 years as a litigation lawyer helps me in seeing all sides of most issues and addressing them, and Rob moderates as well as continues to carry all the operating/hosting costs personally, so another big thanks to Rob for that! Rob and I have only met in person once, when I happened to be in the UK several years ago, interesting to me that we seem to think similarly about many things and have continued to get along so well over the years on this forum. Thanks again, Rob!

Paul LeClair
 
Legs said:
And thanks to you Paul, Rob and many others for keeping the forum on an even keel (congrats).
+1

I was involved in strange situations and can only thank Rob and Paul for their absolutely wise handling of it. I love the way they moderate the forum silently from the background, let many things role until they hit a point of uselessness and only then stop it. It is not always easy to judge what is a bit of rambling and what is a serious dispute. Up to now, they seem to have done a great job in selecting what is what and I can only express my deep felt thanks and respect for this. Thanks again to the moderator team, you guys are doing a great job!
 
The recent editing was certainly due but should not have been needed.
While I wouldn't want to overload Paul or Rob, perhaps the lesson is that the members should be less tolerant of undisguised abuse in the future.
We all have a responsibility to maintain an enjoyable Forum for all of its members.
 
The Sock said:
The recent editing was certainly due but should not have been needed.
While I wouldn't want to overload Paul or Rob, perhaps the lesson is that the members should be less tolerant of undisguised abuse in the future.
We all have a responsibility to maintain an enjoyable Forum for all of its members.

+1.
My call-out post has since disappeared, but I?ll watch, with interest, to see whether it pans out into a longer term improvement
 
I'm currently working on testing & configuring some new software for this forum.  If that's not enough pain, for the second time in two days I've been interrupted by the need to edit/moderate and reply to PMs/emails in respect of unacceptable posts. 

It's good to see that recent posts reflect the behaviours we all signed up to when registering.  Please keep it going or I'll become even grumpier.

Here are some of the recent comments I've seen that give pause for thought -

Totally unnecessary to be so hurtful here!
For outsiders, especially from non-English natives, the jokes are sometimes reminiscent of a form of 'gang codex'. Personally, I get along well with it, but in my opinion it is not ok trampling on sensitivities of others like that.


Might be a surprise to you but there are people who don't like this attitude, these 'funny' remarks and lack of general decency towards others. You even got a lurker to come out the woodwork. What a sorry reason for a first post. And I'm quite sure it won't be many more either.

This is just school ground bullying, no more. And it is what makes this forum a very toxic place most of times.


Those who cause the stinks are conspicuously silent, they know damn well who they are and what's going on. They just do it again another day in another thread.  And those who might agree with Jouni, DaveB, me, etc will eventually just go away like so many before them.

This is not about being funny or understanding English, it is not 'hanging shit' and 'taking the piss', it is plain 'talking shit' and 'pissing vinegar'.
So much hypocrisy here and hate, hate, hate.... no wonder so many people stop posting or don't post at all.

Personally I requested an account here to get in touch with one or two people (succeeded, having our conversation in emails) and to see some pictures that need signing in. I quickly found that the reasons to come back, let alone share some knowledge, help out other Laverda riders/lovers and have some fun did vanish altogether when reading what I described above.


Rob
 
I can wholeheartedly state that I would have been unlikely to buy my first Laverda, an RGS, in September of 2019 if it had not been for this forum. I visited this place frequently during the 2-3 years before I bought it, learning about Laverdas and what to look for in RGS's. Now I also have an SF2 I'm restoring, so it's safe to say this forum has significantly influenced my life - I know understand what fantastic machines they are and moved quickly to get in on it.

FB pages are not a replacement for forums like this; these places are more information dense and important for actual know-how. I consider it pure gold when the very few Laverda experts dispense their hard-earned knowledge here for free, and cannot imagine what got into that feller who pestered Grant out of here. The height of inconsideration. Here's to Grant returning.

Kristian

 
ksoholm said:
I can wholeheartedly state that I would have been unlikely to buy my first Laverda, an RGS, in September of 2019 if it had not been for this forum. I visited this place frequently during the 2-3 years before I bought it, learning about Laverdas and what to look for in RGS's. Now I also have an SF2 I'm restoring, so it's safe to say this forum has significantly influenced my life - I know understand what fantastic machines they are and moved quickly to get in on it.

FB pages are not a replacement for forums like this; these places are more information dense and important for actual know-how. I consider it pure gold when the very few Laverda experts dispense their hard-earned knowledge here for free, and cannot imagine what got into that feller who pestered Grant out of here. The height of inconsideration. Here's to Grant returning.

Kristian

You're right, Facebook is mostly people showing photos of their biceps, or motorcycles.
A lot of them belong to twenty two Laverda pages and post the same photo of their pride and joy, not their wife, on the 22 pages.
At least it keeps the pharmaceutical companies producing anti depressants at bay.

If you'd really read this forum in detail, you wouldn't have plumped for an RGS, you'd have bought the Laverda straight away.

Paul
 
ksoholm said:
I consider it pure gold when the very few Laverda experts dispense their hard-earned knowledge here for free, and cannot imagine what got into that feller who pestered Grant out of here. The height of inconsideration. Here's to Grant returning.

Kristian

Whilst it's always nice to get something for nothing it cannot be guaranteed. As a trader Grant clearly felt his time was better spent elsewhere (his own FB page for example) and voted with his feet/wallet. I expect he'll be back when he has a new build to document/sell...
 
The comments from some of the complainants posted by Rob (Admin) a couple of posts ago surprise me.

While I'm sure they're genuinely upset, and the last thing I'd want to do is dismiss their grievances, it's almost as if I'm reading a different forum. Perhaps it's just me being insensitive, but I haven't seen much of the hate and bullying referred to.

I don't mind admitting that I'm a little on the autism spectrum - touched by the Asperger's Syndrome brush. I'm not particularly adept at picking up social cues or reading hidden meaning in peoples' comments. So it's quite possible that I'm just not seeing what other people are, but it's all rather confusing to me nonetheless.

Anyway, as I've said before. I think the best way to treat any on-line interaction (whether this forum, facebook, twitter, whatever) is to not take it seriously. It's not real life.

If someone says something that is hurtful to you, the chances are that it wasn't meant that way. But even if it was, so what? They most likely don't know you. They've just made an assumption (based on very limited information) that you're a twat. You know that you aren't a twat, so any acrimonious bile they dish out is meaningless. The best way to deal with that sort of thing is to ignore it. It's usually not worth a response.

Regards,
Cam
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top